Logo
  • Cinema
  • Global Selections
  • PartnerNEW
  • Creator
Sign In / Sign Up
  • Cinema
  • Global Selections
  • Curations
  • Readings

More

  • Watchlist
  • PartnerNEW
  • Creator
  • Crowdfunding
  • Past Events

Language & Currency

AndroidiOS
  • Campus Program
  • Online Film Festival Partnerships
  • FAQ
  • Terms of Use
  • Privacy Policy
  • Project Support Terms
  • Contact Us

© 2026 GILOO GROUP LIMITED. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED

Logo

Explore Diverse Films, Experience Inspiring Life Stories, Dive Deep into the World of Giloo

AndroidiOS

Partnerships

Campus ProgramOnline Film Festival Partnerships

Information

FAQTerms of UsePrivacy PolicyProject Support TermsContact Us

© 2026 GILOO GROUP LIMITED. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED

Key visual for 樂觀或悲觀看待科技?導讀《人類未來方程式》
Readings2019.08.21

樂觀或悲觀看待科技?導讀《人類未來方程式》

TechnologyLabor & WorkLife & Death

18世紀中期以前,科技樂觀主義佔了上風,認為科技是人類能力的拓展和延伸,能將人類從辛苦體力勞動與肉身限制中解放出來。例如,大哲學家法蘭西斯.培根(Frances Bacon)透過撰寫《新亞特蘭提斯》(New Atlantis)這本烏托邦小說,倡議國家根據科學原則和技術工藝來建造和經營,才能使人民幸福、社會強⋯⋯

avatarAuthor洪靖
Follow

從原子科學轉向歷史再轉向社會學最後落腳哲學的學術人。想要寫動人散文但最終總是變成論說文的打字者。荷蘭湍特(Twente)大學技術哲學博士。個人網站 blog.hungching.com。

自從人們發現科技擁有強大力量,對技術的看法與評價就逐漸趨於兩極,最終分化成為兩個陣營:科技樂觀主義(techno-optimism)與科技悲觀主義(techno-pessimism)。

18世紀中期以前,科技樂觀主義佔了上風,認為科技是人類能力的拓展和延伸,能將人類從辛苦體力勞動與肉身限制中解放出來。例如,大哲學家法蘭西斯.培根(Frances Bacon)透過撰寫《新亞特蘭提斯》(New Atlantis)這本烏托邦小說,倡議國家根據科學原則和技術工藝來建造和經營,才能使人民幸福、社會強盛。然而,這種「賦予科技眾望」的觀點,到了20世紀中期幾乎全面消退。

經歷18與19世紀兩次工業革命帶來的烏煙瘴氣,以及被馬克思稱為「異化」(alienation)的單調工作模式,人們越來越懷疑科技是否真的帶來好處,再加上20世紀兩次世界大戰中先進武器造成的血腥與傷亡,科技不再被同義於解放,而是困住人類的牢籠。這種科技悲觀主義的典型人物,是另一位大哲學家馬丁.海德格(Martin Heidegger),他批判現代科技把任何事物——包括人類自身——「框架」(enframe)成為可資利用的資源,最終結果不外乎科技掌控人類,而非相反。

時至今日,科技悲觀主義蔚為主流。打開報章雜誌或者網路媒體,不難看到標題中的「科技」一詞總是和「風險」、「衝擊」、「倫理」⋯⋯等相連。每當有新科技出現,人們總是習慣在第一時間查找和預測可能的危險,並以此呼籲停止研發或禁止使用。從人工智慧和自駕車,到人臉辨識和物聯網,各種倫理憂慮持續指稱這些科技將會瓦解人類社會的互信,並且侵蝕我們作為人類的價值。正是在這一片「科技唱衰」聲中,紀錄片《人類未來方程式》(The Future of Work and Death)顯得獨樹一格。

正如英文片名所示,《人類未來方程式》主要探討人類的兩個切身議題——工作和死亡。科技如何影響我們的工作?又會為死亡帶來何種不同風貌?透過採訪科學家、未來主義者、哲學家、社會學家、人類學家⋯⋯等,《人類未來方程式》雖然沒有提供明確答案和判斷,卻精準呈現了科技與社會的複雜關係。更重要的是,它沒有重彈科技悲觀主義的老調,而是給予科技樂觀論者一定的發言空間。

例如,在工作議題方面,《人類未來方程式》雖然照本宣科指出「人工智慧將會造成大量失業」,但也強調新技術往往會創造新職業,比如電腦科技發展之前並沒有一種工作叫做「程式員」(programmer/coder),因此整體而言,人類的職位數量可能不少於以往,只是工作內容產生變化。在死亡議題方面,雖然透過科技延緩或杜絕死亡可能造成人口過剩,甚至有冒犯死亡的宗教意義之虞,《人類未來方程式》也指出當人類擁有更多時間去思考和調整,這些我們現在視之為問題的種種,很可能不會出現,或者不至於成為問題。

會不會到了那個時候,死亡反而變成人類的追求與目的?如果死亡仍是人類自我認同的標誌,那麼我們是否應該發展「死的技術」,讓人類能夠選擇死亡的過程與方式?

更多的辯證與細節,就有待讀者透過觀影領會一二。我想在這裡特別指出的是,《人類未來方程式》其實暗示了某種介於科技樂觀與悲觀主義之間的第三種視角。這種視角不以科技發展為傲,要求社會與之配合,也不以人類道德為繩,要求技術以其為準。這種視角聚焦的是:「什麼樣的科技」與「什麼樣的社會」之間的搭配。如果機器能夠承擔人類所有體力或腦力工作,那麼是否仍需把工作視為人類生存的必須之一?如果我們無論如何珍視某些工作,那麼是否能夠透過科技來增加這些工作的價值、甚至使人們更樂於其中?同樣地,如果科技能夠讓人類免於死亡,那麼我們應該如何看待時間?會不會到了那個時候,死亡反而變成人類的追求與目的?如果死亡仍是人類自我認同的標誌,那麼我們是否應該發展「死的技術」,讓人類能夠選擇死亡的過程與方式?

這種視角不樂觀亦不悲觀,而是一種「共伴」(co-accompaniment)的態度,聚焦在科技與社會的雙向關係,亦步亦趨同時照看、形塑科技和社會的樣貌。要知道,不論是科技樂觀主義或悲觀主義,兩者都沒有成功預言過科技對社會的影響。電視的推廣者曾說,電視能提供更充足、便捷、和真實的影像資訊,因此將會促使民智大開並健全民主制度。同樣的,蘇格拉底(Socrates)曾經大力反對書寫技術,因為使用紙筆無異詆毀人類的記憶能力,甚至鼓勵遺忘。顯然,這些預測從未成真,如今也沒人會把這些話當真。

共伴的概念,有助於克服科技樂觀和悲觀主義的無力。科學怪人之所以嚇人和害人,正是因為科學家弗蘭肯斯坦(Frankenstein)創造它之後就雙手一攤,讓它獨自面對社會、和其他人類接觸。如果我們承認,孩子需要細心的協助和培養才能安然成長,那麼其實科技亦當如是——畢竟,他/它們都是我們的創生物(creatures)。

In this issue

1 film

The Future of Work and Death
Giloo Exclusive
Not available in your region

The Future of Work and Death

Popular

To Be Ordinary | When Life No Longer Goes as Planned, Do We Still Need to Prove Our Worth?
Reading

To Be Ordinary | When Life No Longer Goes as Planned, Do We Still Need to Prove Our Worth?

Giloo紀實影音/2026.11.11

A sudden car accident brings an estranged family back together. The son loses the ability to walk, his unemployed father takes on the responsibility of caring for him, his mother struggles to hold the family together, and his young sister gradually grows up amid the upheaval. Directed by Lee Yun-chan, To Be Ordinary portrays how an ordinary family, caught between loss and gain, comes to understand one another anew—and asks how a person’s worth should ultimately be measured.

Inside South Korea’s Night of Martial Law: Six Films at the 2026 Golden Horse Judicial Film Festival Explore Democracy, Violence, and Healing
Reading

Inside South Korea’s Night of Martial Law: Six Films at the 2026 Golden Horse Judicial Film Festival Explore Democracy, Violence, and Healing

Giloo紀實影音/2026.11.05

In 2026, the Golden Horse Film Festival and the Judicial Yuan join forces for the eighth year to present the “Golden Horse X Judicial Film Festival.” The event has earned widespread acclaim from the industry and audiences alike, while its post-screening Judicial Forum draws not only general moviegoers but also many law students who come to listen and take part in the discussions. This year’s six outstanding selections—To Be Ordinary, Shadow Work, The Seoul Guardians, Prosecution, 17, and A Place to Heal—will all have their Taiwan premieres. Through cinema, audiences will witness the challenges of criminal investigations, the circumstances faced by sexual assault survivors, and the remorse and compensation that follow a traffic accident. The films also open up broader institutional discussions closely connected to Taiwanese society, including constitutional democracy, child and adolescent mental healthcare, and domestic violence protection orders. In addition to the Taipei Golden Horse Film Festival, the films will be screened in Taichung and Kaohsiung, with post-screening talks. Since tickets went on sale last Sunday, many Taipei screenings have sold out within moments. Interested audiences are encouraged to take advantage of the screenings in Taichung and Kaohsiung.

Hiroshi Abe Makes a Surprise Visit to Taiwan! Five Mystery Films Unveiled at the 2026 Taipei Golden Horse Film Festival, Featuring Oscar-Winning Stars in Electrifying Performances
Reading

Hiroshi Abe Makes a Surprise Visit to Taiwan! Five Mystery Films Unveiled at the 2026 Taipei Golden Horse Film Festival, Featuring Oscar-Winning Stars in Electrifying Performances

Giloo紀實影音/2026.10.29

Online ticket sales for the 2026 Taipei Golden Horse Film Festival opened on the official website last Sunday (10/25), breaking the festival’s opening-day box office record thanks to the enthusiastic support of film fans! Today (10/29), in addition to announcing additional screenings, the festival revealed five mystery films, including A List for Tomorrow, starring acclaimed Japanese actor Hiroshi Abe, who will attend its world premiere at the Taipei Golden Horse Film Festival; You Can See Everything, hailed as one of the year’s must-see films, has also joined the lineup in response to fervent demand from fans; The Only Living Pickpocket in New York, starring Cannes Best Actor winner John Turturro and acclaimed at the Sundance and Berlin film festivals; Bunker, featuring Oscar-winning real-life couple Javier Bardem and Penélope Cruz acting opposite each other; and Your Mother Your Mother Your Mother, in which Oscar-winning Best Supporting Actor Mahershala Ali takes on the role of the ultimate father.