Logo
  • Cinema
  • Global Selections
  • PartnerNEW
  • Creator
Sign In / Sign Up
  • Cinema
  • Global Selections
  • Curations
  • Readings

More

  • Watchlist
  • PartnerNEW
  • Creator
  • Crowdfunding
  • Past Events

Language & Currency

AndroidiOS
  • Campus Program
  • Online Film Festival Partnerships
  • FAQ
  • Terms of Use
  • Privacy Policy
  • Project Support Terms
  • Contact Us

© 2026 GILOO GROUP LIMITED. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED

Logo

Explore Diverse Films, Experience Inspiring Life Stories, Dive Deep into the World of Giloo

AndroidiOS

Partnerships

Campus ProgramOnline Film Festival Partnerships

Information

FAQTerms of UsePrivacy PolicyProject Support TermsContact Us

© 2026 GILOO GROUP LIMITED. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED

Key visual for 《最後的自由時光》: 來自死刑犯家屬的沉痛呢喃
Readings2020.04.23

《最後的自由時光》: 來自死刑犯家屬的沉痛呢喃

美國JusticeCinemaLife & Death

最後的自由時光,究竟何時是Manny最後的自由,是執行死刑前?犯案前?遭逮捕前?或是參與戰爭前?在罹患精神疾病後,活在地獄的人,又有什麼時候是真正的自由時光?我只希望說完這些故事的Bill,可以真正自由而不帶枷鎖活著。若是本片是一個沉重且深刻的怒吼,那請讓更多人看見,思考後存在的回音,可能就是我們能給受害者們最後的安慰了⋯⋯

avatarAuthor三分熟
Follow

以為可以活在夢中,卻發現工作是如此真實,把繼續浪漫,當成人生課題的法 律人。

1980年,Manny Babbitt因為在侵入住居行搶中,殺害78歲的Leah Schendel,經陪審團判處死刑,在入獄約20年後,於1999年5月4日以注射毒液方式執行死刑。這幾行簡短、敘述性的文字紀錄了Manny犯案到執行死刑這段長達20年的時間,而如同這段冰冷的文字,在執行死刑後,這兩條生命就應該像被冷凍到地底,漸漸被世人遺忘。直到2015年《最後的自由時光》短片問世,訴說任何失去的生命都不曾被忘記,Leah Schendel不會被遺忘,Manny 也不該被遺忘。


《最後的自由時光》劇照

本片以Manny兄長Bill Babbitt訪談的過程為軸心,描繪出Manny 從出生到遭執行死刑的日子(美國並非是廢除死刑的國家,部分州仍存在死刑),透過拍攝真人訪談過程,再以動畫方式顯現,除了讓Bill的回憶能更以畫面、象徵方式呈現外,透過除去Bill的膚色,以強烈方式傳達對於Manny案中種族歧視的抗議。Bill平實卻富含遺憾的口吻,撕去死刑犯「怪獸」標籤,刻劃出的Manny的真實人生,從小因車禍而導致學習緩慢,輟學、從軍參與越戰、戰後罹患創傷後壓力症候群、妄想型思覺失調症、住過精神病院、離婚、成為遊民,然後犯案。在審判過程中,因大選將至而求處死刑的檢察官,未盡辯護責任的律師,全白人的陪審團,結構性的導致Manny遭判處死刑,且遭執行死刑。這類案件在當時實在不算少見,以描繪Bryan Stevenson律師真實故事的《不完美正義電影》中Herbert Richardson也是因參與越戰而患有精神疾病,犯下殺人案件而遭判處並執行死刑的案件。

《最後的自由時光》劇照

Manny案件不會被稱為嚴格定義下的「冤案」,死刑議題上被拿來討論最多的就是司法誤判的危險性,但抽掉誤判的討論後,Manny案更能反應出精神病患、弱勢社經地位的被告在整個司法程序中所面臨的困境。Bill原先是一個支持死刑論者,但從局外人角色變成死刑犯的家屬,甚至是因自己的舉發而讓弟弟遭查獲,透過講述者角色的切換,引發觀看者去內化省思種族歧視、精神疾病、司法制度、死刑議題。Bill在Manny執行死刑時,看到Leah的家屬,猜想他們對於死刑的期待,受害者家屬的苦痛,確實讓人動搖,但死刑犯家屬的角度確實是在整個議題面向中最被忽視的聲音,也最容易被連坐法式汙名化的角色。Bill對於Manny的種種不捨,並非淡化犯行,反而更是思考司法制度進步的契機。

歐陽修《瀧岡阡表》中:「求其生而不得,則死者與我皆無恨也」,意思大概是若已經盡力替死刑犯尋求求生機會,但仍然找不到活路,那麼被判死罪的人與我都沒有遺憾。但這段說寫來簡單,但做起來永遠都是無比艱難的,就像張娟芬老師在《殺戮的艱難》所提到的,「我的論點不是生命的可貴,我的論點是殺戮的艱難,唯其如此,我們才保住好人與壞人之間,那一點點的差別。」。

最後的自由時光,究竟何時是Manny最後的自由,是執行死刑前?犯案前?遭逮捕前?或是參與戰爭前?在罹患精神疾病後,活在地獄的人,又有什麼時候是真正的自由時光?我只希望說完這些故事的Bill,可以真正自由而不帶枷鎖活著。若是本片是一個沉重且深刻的怒吼,那請讓更多人看見,思考後存在的回音,可能就是我們能給受害者們最後的安慰了。

 

 


線上影展《司法院Class:為誰辯護?》|影展連結
更多資訊|司法院FB粉絲專頁

In this issue

1 film

Last Day of Freedom
Not available in your region

Last Day of Freedom

Popular

To Be Ordinary | When Life No Longer Goes as Planned, Do We Still Need to Prove Our Worth?
Reading

To Be Ordinary | When Life No Longer Goes as Planned, Do We Still Need to Prove Our Worth?

Giloo紀實影音/2026.11.11

A sudden car accident brings an estranged family back together. The son loses the ability to walk, his unemployed father takes on the responsibility of caring for him, his mother struggles to hold the family together, and his young sister gradually grows up amid the upheaval. Directed by Lee Yun-chan, To Be Ordinary portrays how an ordinary family, caught between loss and gain, comes to understand one another anew—and asks how a person’s worth should ultimately be measured.

Inside South Korea’s Night of Martial Law: Six Films at the 2026 Golden Horse Judicial Film Festival Explore Democracy, Violence, and Healing
Reading

Inside South Korea’s Night of Martial Law: Six Films at the 2026 Golden Horse Judicial Film Festival Explore Democracy, Violence, and Healing

Giloo紀實影音/2026.11.05

In 2026, the Golden Horse Film Festival and the Judicial Yuan join forces for the eighth year to present the “Golden Horse X Judicial Film Festival.” The event has earned widespread acclaim from the industry and audiences alike, while its post-screening Judicial Forum draws not only general moviegoers but also many law students who come to listen and take part in the discussions. This year’s six outstanding selections—To Be Ordinary, Shadow Work, The Seoul Guardians, Prosecution, 17, and A Place to Heal—will all have their Taiwan premieres. Through cinema, audiences will witness the challenges of criminal investigations, the circumstances faced by sexual assault survivors, and the remorse and compensation that follow a traffic accident. The films also open up broader institutional discussions closely connected to Taiwanese society, including constitutional democracy, child and adolescent mental healthcare, and domestic violence protection orders. In addition to the Taipei Golden Horse Film Festival, the films will be screened in Taichung and Kaohsiung, with post-screening talks. Since tickets went on sale last Sunday, many Taipei screenings have sold out within moments. Interested audiences are encouraged to take advantage of the screenings in Taichung and Kaohsiung.

Hiroshi Abe Makes a Surprise Visit to Taiwan! Five Mystery Films Unveiled at the 2026 Taipei Golden Horse Film Festival, Featuring Oscar-Winning Stars in Electrifying Performances
Reading

Hiroshi Abe Makes a Surprise Visit to Taiwan! Five Mystery Films Unveiled at the 2026 Taipei Golden Horse Film Festival, Featuring Oscar-Winning Stars in Electrifying Performances

Giloo紀實影音/2026.10.29

Online ticket sales for the 2026 Taipei Golden Horse Film Festival opened on the official website last Sunday (10/25), breaking the festival’s opening-day box office record thanks to the enthusiastic support of film fans! Today (10/29), in addition to announcing additional screenings, the festival revealed five mystery films, including A List for Tomorrow, starring acclaimed Japanese actor Hiroshi Abe, who will attend its world premiere at the Taipei Golden Horse Film Festival; You Can See Everything, hailed as one of the year’s must-see films, has also joined the lineup in response to fervent demand from fans; The Only Living Pickpocket in New York, starring Cannes Best Actor winner John Turturro and acclaimed at the Sundance and Berlin film festivals; Bunker, featuring Oscar-winning real-life couple Javier Bardem and Penélope Cruz acting opposite each other; and Your Mother Your Mother Your Mother, in which Oscar-winning Best Supporting Actor Mahershala Ali takes on the role of the ultimate father.